Age Discrimination Case Over HIPAA Violation: Federal Court Rules in Favor of Main Line Health

by | Jul 12, 2018

In 2016, Radnor, PA-based Main Line Health Inc., fired a member of staff for breaching Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) Rules by viewing the personal records of a co-worker without authorization on two different occasions.

In such instances, when staff or patient records are accessed without official permission, employees face disciplinary action which can include firing. Gloria Terrell was one such staff member who was terminated for breaching company policies and HIPAA Rules. Main Line Health sacked Terrell for “co-worker snooping.”

Terrell submitted an internal appeal over her firing and maintained she accessed the records of a co-worker in order to locate a contact telephone number. Terrell said she had to contact the co-worker to make sure a work shift would be covered, and this constituted a legitimate business reason for the access as she could not find the phone list with employees’ contact numbers.

After sacking Terrell, Main Line Health hired a significantly younger person to fill the vacant role. Terrell began legal action against Main Line Health in September 2016 claiming age discrimination. In the legal action, Terrell alleged Main Line Health had experienced similar snooping incidents in the past and failed to apply the same sanctions for younger member of staff. Terrell claimed she was aware of three younger co-workers who were not fired after the discovery of HIPAA violations. However, Terrell could not prove those assertions and all three staff members denied they had been involved in any improper accessing of patient records.

Main Line Health said that appropriate training on HIPAA Rules and company policies had been given to staff on multiple occasions and that there were policies in place in relation to the protection of confidential employee and patient information. Those policies clearly state disciplinary action will be applied if company policies and HIPAA Rules are breached, which may include immediate discharge from employment.

Main Line Health argued Terrell was terminated for a legitimate, non-discriminatory reason, and since the case did not raise a triable issue, Main Line Health was entitled to a summary judgement.

Terrell’s case (Gloria Terrell v. Main Line Health, Inc., et al – Civil action No. 17-3102) was put forward to federal court in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. U.S District Court Judge Richard Barclay Surrick recently granted Main Line Health’s summary judgement, ruling Terrell did not establish a viable age discrimination claim.

Judge Barclay Surric wrote “In short, other than her own subjective beliefs, Plaintiff has offered no evidence from which a reasonable factfinder could conclude that Defendant’s proffered reason for terminating her lacks credibility. She has provided no evidence to support a finding of discrimination. Although one may have reservations about the wisdom of terminating an employee with Plaintiff’s experience and tenure for electronically accessing a phone number that had already been made available to co-workers in paper form, it is not for this Court to sit as a super-personnel department that re-examines an entity’s business decisions.”

Raise the level of HIPAA Awareness in your organization with Learner-Friendly, Comprehensive and Affordable HIPAA Training.


Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Patrick Kennedy

Patrick Kennedy is a highly accomplished journalist and editor with nearly two decades of experience in the field. With expertise in writing and editing content, Patrick has made significant contributions to various publications and organizations. Over the course of his career, Patrick has successfully managed teams of writers, overseeing the production of high-quality content and ensuring its adherence to professional standards. His exceptional leadership skills, combined with his deep understanding of journalistic principles, have allowed him to create cohesive and engaging narratives that resonate with readers. A notable area of specialization for Patrick lies in compliance, particularly in relation to HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act). He has authored numerous articles delving into the complexities of compliance and its implications for various industries. Patrick's comprehensive understanding of HIPAA regulations has positioned him as a go-to expert, sought after for his insights and expertise in this field. Patrick's bachelors degree is from the University of Limerick and his master's degree in journalism is from Dublin City University. You can contact Patrick through his LinkedIn profile:

Raise the level of HIPAA Awareness in your organization with Learner-Friendly, Comprehensive and Affordable HIPAA Training.

Comprehensive HIPAA Training

Used in 1000+ Healthcare Organizations and 100+ Universities

    Full Course - Immediate Access

    Privacy Policy