Arkansas Court Rules that PHI Retention by Employees is not a HIPAA Breach

by | Jul 16, 2015

Two employees who retained the Protected Health Information (PHI) of patients after their employment at Arkansas Children’s Hospital was terminated, did not violate the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) according to a rulign made by the U.S District Court of the Western Division of the Eastern District of Arkansas.

Pam and Eben Howard took an action against Arkansas Children’s Hospital – Dr. Ron Robertson and Jon Bates – after their contracts of employment were terminated. They believed their their jobs were terminated because they highlighted a number of problems relating to how the healthcare provider billed the government. They have claimed that the healthcare supplier violated the 1st and 14th Amendments, the Arkansas Civil Rights Act, the Public Policy of the State of Arkansas and the False Claims Act.

While working at ACH, the pair collected a considerable volume of PHI of patients. After what the pair thought to be unfair termination of contracts, the PHI was not returned. It was also given to an unauthorized third party.

Under usual circumstances, any employee retaining PHI of patients after employment is terminated would be breaching HIPAA Rules. Data should only be accessed by authorized people. While the pair were authorized to view the data, those access rights stopped when their employment contract ended. They should not have disclosed that information to any other unauthorized person. However, there are some exceptions to these privacy rules.

The plaintiffs claim that they were allowed to retain PHI and disclose it to their attorney, as they come within HIPAA’s whistleblower protections; a claim which is denied by the healthcare supplier. ACH maintains that the Howards breached HIPAA Rules by keeping data and giving it to their attorney.

A motion was submitted by the defendants for a partial summary judgement on the basis that the Howards were not entitled to protection as whitstleblowers under the False Claims Act. The court thought differently.

No HIPAA violation was caused because the plaintiffs were memebrs of staff at the hospital prior to termination – when PHI was collected; the plaintiffs believed that the hospital was acting in an illegal manner and violated professional standards; and the disclosure of PHI was to an attorney, solely for the purpose of obtaining legal opinion.

The partial summary judgement was denied, with the court decreeing “To the extent that the defendants seek judgment that the plaintiffs are not whistleblowers under HIPAA, the motion is denied on the merits.”

Raise the level of HIPAA Awareness in your organization with Learner-Friendly, Comprehensive and Affordable HIPAA Training.


Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Patrick Kennedy

Patrick Kennedy is a highly accomplished journalist and editor with nearly two decades of experience in the field. With expertise in writing and editing content, Patrick has made significant contributions to various publications and organizations. Over the course of his career, Patrick has successfully managed teams of writers, overseeing the production of high-quality content and ensuring its adherence to professional standards. His exceptional leadership skills, combined with his deep understanding of journalistic principles, have allowed him to create cohesive and engaging narratives that resonate with readers. A notable area of specialization for Patrick lies in compliance, particularly in relation to HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act). He has authored numerous articles delving into the complexities of compliance and its implications for various industries. Patrick's comprehensive understanding of HIPAA regulations has positioned him as a go-to expert, sought after for his insights and expertise in this field. Patrick's bachelors degree is from the University of Limerick and his master's degree in journalism is from Dublin City University. You can contact Patrick through his LinkedIn profile:

Raise the level of HIPAA Awareness in your organization with Learner-Friendly, Comprehensive and Affordable HIPAA Training.

Comprehensive HIPAA Training

Used in 1000+ Healthcare Organizations and 100+ Universities

    Full Course - Immediate Access

    Privacy Policy